International Workers’ Day; Immigration Reform; Gas Drilling Industrialization

May 1st  was International Workers’ Day.  Some call it   “The Real Labor Day.”

In 1886,  the American Federation of Labor (AFL)  called on workers to strike any business that refused to abide by an 8-hour  workday.   According to Howard Zinn’s  A People’s History of the United States, (1995, p. 264)  on May 1,  1886,

350,000 workers in 11,562 establishments all over the country went out on strike.  In Chicago, 40,000 struck and 45,000 were granted a shorter working day to prevent them from striking.  Every railroad in Chicago stopped running and most of the industries in Chicago were paralyzed.  The stockyards were closed down.”

In 1880,  The United States’ population was approximately 50 million and  Chicago’s   was 500,000. According to the 1880 Census Compendium Part II,  there were   2.8 million  men, women and children working in the nation’s 254,000  manufacturing  facilities.  Using  Zinn’s figures then,  approximately 13% of US workers  went out on strike  May 1, 1886.

Imagine if,  in 2009,  13% of  the US’  140 million “documented”  workers had struck for  universal health care  and a living wage.   Go ahead.  Imagine  18 million  workers thronging the  streets, hand-in-hand, to advocate  for themselves, their children and the future of this nation.

In 1983,  the year my oldest son was born, we were in the middle of another “economic downturn.”  A gallon of gas cost $1.25,  a Dodge Ram truck cost $5700 and the average monthly rent was  $335.  Cleaning toilets and pushing a lawnmower earned me $10 an hour.  (When I saved enough to buy my father’s old riding mower, I was able to ask $15 an hour for larger properties.)

Seventeen years later, after the boom times of the 1990’s,  most of us freelance “domestic workers”  could make  $15-20 an hour.  Around that same time, our counterparts in New York City were  being paid  in the $25-30 range.

In July  2009 — the costs of most everything having doubled since 1983 —   the US  minimum wage was raised to $7.25 per hour.

This past May 1st,  I worked and was glad for it  though I know  Grandma and Grandpa were  rolling in their graves.  (May 1st was the date my family eschewed labor for history;  the day we  remembered  Samuel Gompers,  the AFL  and the perfidy of  police officers who helped  smother labor’s demands for living wages, humane working conditions and  equal pay regardless of  gender and race.)

On May 1, 2010,  I informed a prospective employer  that “I’d have to charge $20 an hour to clean his house”  and cited to the round-trip  travel time, cost of products, gas,  fuel oil, rent, etc.

The weighty pause on the other end of the phone and the aghast rejoinder took me by surprise,  “We won’t pay that.  We don’t pay more than $15 an hour in the City.”

“That’s interesting,”  said I.  “A few years ago,  the going rate for housekeepers in the City was nearer $25-30 an hour.”

“Not anymore,”  came the smug-sounding reply.

There are times when my naivete is unforgivable.

I asked another  “City dweller” — a member of a  white collar union  and gas drilling opponent —   what the going rate for domestic services  is in her neighborhood.  “Ten dollars an hour,”  she answered.  “But that’s because we have so many ‘illegals.'”

“‘Illegals?  You mean ‘undocumented workers?'”

She shrugged.

So for those of you who oppose gas drilling and own homes  in the City as well as in our rural Pennsylvania and New York communities, remember this simple action + action = results equation:

When you pay less than subsistence wages to  the “undocumented human”  who has to buy groceries and pay rent  in Manhattan,  Brooklyn or Long Island,

YOU  DRIVE DOWN  the wages of the person struggling  beside you in Callicoon, Milanville and Honesdale and


When I raised this issue of wage depression with friends who live both rurally and in the City,  I was told their  ability to share the wealth is constrained  by their loss of retirement funds;  that their “disposable” income has been drastically reduced  by cutbacks in their businesses and occupations.

I understand.  My bank account plunged right beside yours and Sullivan County’s  real unemployment figure is nearer 20% than the officially cited  10.9%

So given that we’re all in  greatly reduced circumstances,  here’s my deal:  I’ll reduce my housekeeping charges by $5  to $15 an hour if you’ll promise to increase my counterpart’s  wage in the City to a  $15 cash rate.

If you can still afford to hire domestic help, for your own sake,  pay them a living wage.  Otherwise, whose disposable income will  keep you in business?

I saved money during the 1983 downturn.  I paid the hospital and obstetrician  cash for their services.

The son born to me in 1983  was admitted to the New York State Bar last week.  If he was born today,  I doubt he’d ever see the inside of a law school.

Breathing is Political because our personal political, economic and social decisions influence the growth of a child in our neighbor’s womb.  A child’s life depends, in large part,  on the health of the mother and on  the parents’  ability to provide nutritious meals, books, ideas, a secure home and a realistic dream for the future.

For all workers, the breadth of that dream and its attainability  depend on you and me  caring about equitable treatment for all.  It does NOT depend on any one of us short-changing another simply because we can.

As for union workers who de-value the work and lives  of others’,  as I write this,  America’s teachers’ unions are the new target of labor reforms.  If the rest of us are busy scrabbling for each spare nickle,  when will we have leisure to come to your defense?

7 thoughts on “International Workers’ Day; Immigration Reform; Gas Drilling Industrialization”

  1. Leave a Comment

    Sure. I’ll leave a comment.

    No, wait.

    I’ll leave Liz and others an article that was written today about gas drilling, Assemblywoman Gunther, Callicoon, Sullivan County, NY and two guys who are raring to drill…baby, drill!


  2. Ms. Crosby, What’s your take on the article? There are several opinions expressed in it and I’m not sure from your comment what yours is. Liz

  3. Bravo! Thank you for writing this article and making people realize there is a human element on the other side of their decisions. I am one of those dual dwellers (apt in NYC and home in PA)..I can tell you we pay a little over $20 dollars an hour to have someone clean our 900 sq ft apartment in the city. My Mom, a single mother from the time I was 10 years old, found herself having to work two and three jobs just to make ends meet. Most of these secondary jobs were cleaning the homes/apts of wealthy individuals. She found an amazing group of people who paid her fairly and treated her with kindness. I learned many big life lessons early in childhood by being witness to my mother’s struggles…which is why I am mindful of these things today. I dislike the word “illegals” the same way I dislike the words “nimby” and “foreigners”…..they are negative coined phrases meant to lessen the beliefs of some and dehumanize others. I have no tolerance for that type of language. We bought this house in this beautiful rural area to become part of the community. We proudly buy local, I support my neighbors by hiring them to do yard/home projects, we find ourselves eating every weekend at Cafe Devine to support a new business in our community (if you haven’t tried her grilled cheese sandwich I suggest putting this on your Sullivan County Bucket List :>). Your blog is a priceless community resource…you should have our support so you can continue to write and keep this gift going. I am happy to pay because it’s the right thing to fact it’s our responsibility to do so if we expect our communities to blossom.


    P.S. If you have an apartment in the city and a home in the country you can afford to pay $20 dollars an hour for someone’s time..please have respect for others!

  4. Dear Liz–

    You are indeed a precious resource for our community. You are an honest broker pouring good work, much time, and scrupulous research into the collective community here in our beloved Catskills. Thanks for this piece.


  5. Thank you Tanyette and John. I think it’s much easier to “short-change” someone if you think of them as “the housekeeper” or the “plumber” or the “painter” than if you think of them as an integral part of the community on whom we all depend. I always think of the businesspeople and laborers who work all day and then hit the floor running when the fire siren blows in the middle of the night.

    It’s also too easy to vilify people with ugly names like “flatlanders.” I used to live in New Haven and endured its congestion and that dreadful head-jangling trip to the mountains on Route 95. We all sacrifice to call our river valley home and to keep it vibrant. We need fresh eyes and “new blood.” Too many of our children can’t make a home here. Without the taxes and small business supports provided by “weekenders,” I dread to think how many of our shopkeepers would have to close their doors.

    The irony is that we all live here because we like the personal flavor of the place. Never mind the beauty, that goes without saying. But we enjoy the profound humanity that comes with knowing that the waitress who serves us our food is in her third year of college and is working toward a degree in public health. It makes us feel part of another’s life. It gives us a reason to cheer. It gives us our sense of belonging.

    If we can’t get this right in a place like ours, where our interdependence is so clear, I despair for the rest of the world.

  6. So to recap, if “dual dwellers” paid their NYC “undocumented” housekeepers an extra 5 dollars an hour, then they would also feel inclined to pay their Sullivan County housekeepers an extra 5 dollars an hour, and the potential for that housekeeper to make $31,200/year rather than $20,800 would ensure that they turn down a million dollar, five year lease from an oil company?

    I don’t think the solution to these problems is in the exact weight of scraps the wealthy choose to toss to the poor.

    Why defend isolationism as a county (I bought a bottle of your local yogurt, farmer John! You’re welcome!) but abhor it as racist as a countRy? (Not alot of farm grants this year, farmer John? Don’t blame me, I assume a portion of all of my shadow-economy-service-industry dollars somehow found their way to the US treasury. Oh, and don’t you dare take that million dollar five year lease the oil company’s offering you, my Tuscany Summer getaway this year is two days shorter so that I can pay your wife an extra five bucks an hour for housekeeping!)

Let us know what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Breathing Is Political

Think. Write. Examine


Indigenous Issues and Resistance

Pennsylvania Alliance for Clean Water and Air

Dedicated citizens fighting to protect our most valuable resources.


wrestling with congruency


Gas Drilling Awareness for Cortland County is the best place for your personal blog or business site.

%d bloggers like this: